Nuclear roundup: history repeats?

By Kennedy Maize

The funereal theme of the first generation of U.S. civilian nuclear power was “off schedule and over budget.” Dozens of projects in development from the 1970s up to about a decade ago crashed and burned economically, leaving Investors and consumer holding expensive, radioactive bags.

What to do? The nuclear establishment adopted the advice of the great American philosopher Lawrence “Yogi” Berra (1925-2015): “When you come to a fork in the road…. take it.”

Trying to learn the lessons from those bad days, the nuclear establishment came up with a path to a nuclear renaissance: first, small modular reactors, not so expensive up front, built in cookie cutter fashion, aka SMRs.

Next, “advanced” technologies, departing from proven light water moderated and cooled machines with low enriched fuel. Many weren’t new, but earlier tried and abandoned, often by the now-defunct Atomic Energy Commission.

A decade later, the old pattern may be developing. Again, Yogi Berra had an apposite take: “It’s déjà vu all over again.”

Let’s start in Canada, which rejected the U.S. LWR paradigm, preferring pressurized heavy water reactors with natural uranium fuel, known as “CANDU” reactors.

Provincial utility Ontario Power Generation, which operates 10 CANDU reactors at two sites, on May 8, 2025 announced it was joining the SMR stampede. OPG said it would build four new GE Vernova Hitachi BWRX-300 MW boiling light water reactors at its Darlington station, currently featuring four CANDU reactors with 3,512-MW of capacity.

OPG bragged, “Imagine a technology that could produce clean, low-carbon power, be factory-assembled and delivered anywhere in the world, and provide reliable, affordable energy to homes, district heating to entire communities, or power for heavy industry. That’s the promise of small modular reactors (SMRs), the next-generation of nuclear technology that is set to be deployed by Ontario Power Generation (OPG) right here in Ontario – the first place to do so in North America.”

In April, OPG announced the start of construction, lowering a 953-tonne steel and concrete slab onto a 35-meter-deep shaft, completing reactor base mat. Oil Price commented, “Construction has begun on the Western world’s first grid-scale Small Modular Reactor (SMR), though small is not what comes to mind, considering that the machine will fit on two soccer fields.” OPG said the first unit would go online in 2030.

OPG at work on its small modular reactor

On Nov. 10 OPG backtracked. The utility said it “has identified pressures that will impact Unit 1’s cost and schedule. Based on the assessment completed to date, Unit 1 is no longer expected to meet the previously disclosed October 2030 commercial-operation target or be completed within the previously disclosed budget.” Stay tuned.

Moving from Ontario to Oregon, home of SMR progenitor NuScale Power (NYSE:SMR), possessor of the only U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission generic design license for the company’s 50 and 75 MW reactors. They are fundamentally shrunken and restructured conventional reactors.

NuScale got an early start out of the SMR box quickly running into the off schedule, over budget conundrum. The company lined up a deal with Utah Associated Municipal Power Systems (UAMPS), a joint action public power agency with 47 members in Utah, California, Idaho, Nevada, New Mexico, and Wyoming.

The deal soon got wobbly as the price tag rose from $4 billion to $6 billion. UAMPS pulled out. NuScale has struggled since. Investor Fluor Corp. pulled out, the company restructured,  share prices went into free fall from $50/share to under $5.

The company now faces a class action lawsuit by disgruntled shareholders, brought Nov. 11 by New York City’s Rosen Law Firm, a securities litigation specialist. The suit in U.S. District Court for Oregon alleges that NuScale executives mislead investors about its financial stability, overstated a potential deal with the Tennessee Valley Authority, and is in a “remaining cash runway.”

Finally, in Texas, where Fermi Inc., (NASDAQ: FRMI), doing business as Fermi America, plans a wildly ambitious 17-GW, $60-billion “Project Matador” data center in the arid Texas panhandle. It plans an all-of-the-above generation mix, topped by four conventional Westinghouse AP-1000 reactors.

In its recent quarterly filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, Fermi announced that Mesut Uzman, the chief nuclear construction officer, “departed the Company.” Fermi also revised its schedule for commissioning the nukes to 2034 to 2037, compared to 2033 to 2036 in prior filings.

Yogi Berra

Fermi’s 10Q filing came before Texas midterm elections, where Democrats swept to win every statewide office on the ballot, likely increasing data center skepticism. Outgoing Republican Gov. Greg Abbott had already “paused” new construction.

Returning to the yogi’s summary of the nuclear tale. Lawrence Berra: “We made too many wrong mistakes.”

The Quad Report, covering energy policy and politics